|
|
||||||||
CLINICAL STUDIES |
Pediatric Diabetes Unit, Department of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine, Saarland University Hospital, Homburg/Saar, Germany
1 Pediatric Diabetes Unit, Hospital for Children and Adolescents, University of Leipzig, Leipzig, Germany
2 Pediatric Diabetes Unit, Hospital for Children and Adolescents
3 Department of Epidemiology, University of Ulm, Ulm, Germany
4 Pediatric Diabetes Unit, Hospital for Children and Adolescents, Charité, Berlin, Germany
5 Pediatric Diabetes Unit, Hospital for Children and Adolescents, University of Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany
(Correspondence should be addressed to T Rohrer who is now at Department of Pediatrics and Neonatology, Saarland University Hospital, Kirrberger Str. 1, Geb. 9, 66421 Homburg/Saar, Germany Email: kitroh{at}uniklinikum-saarland.de)
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Research design and methods: Initiated in 1990, the Diabetes-Patienten-Verlaufsdaten (DPV) is an ongoing, prospective longitudinal follow-up program to benchmark the quality of diabetes care provided to, predominantly, pediatric patients. Data collection for this non-interventional audit was carried out at 202 German diabetes treatment centers. Patient recruitment was done by referral, clinic/hospital ascertainment, or self-report. Data were analyzed for subcohorts of 1218–2409 boys and 579–2640 girls from a cohort of 24 385 pediatric type 1 diabetic patients. Selection was based on ethnicity and availability of data on Tanner stage 2, or higher, of genital and pubic hair development (boys) or breast and pubic hair development, and menarche (girls).
Results: Boys showed significant (P<0.05) delay (years) in mean ages at onset of genital development (12.0 (±0.9) years) and pubarche (12.2 (±0.4) years). In girls, mean ages at thelarche (11.4 (±0.5) years), pubarche (11.5 (±0.1) years), and menarche (13.2 (±0.5) years) were significantly delayed compared with the general population. Sexual maturity (Tanner stage 5) was not delayed in either sex. Elevated glycohemoglobin and decreased BMI SDS were associated with significantly delayed pubertal onset, whereas relative diabetes duration and insulin dose were not.
Conclusions: Pubertal onset, but not sexual maturity, is delayed in children with type 1 diabetes. Delay increases with higher glycohemoglobin and lower BMI SDS.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
After several conceptual changes since its inception in 1990, the DPV documentation and quality management system comprises three basic modules: a) the DPV software for prospective diabetes documentation; b) the benchmarking and quality control procedure (QC-DPV); and c) DPV-SCIENT, a cumulative diabetes research database (9). Using the DPV software, currently more than 200 participating centers regularly enter their data into the database on a semi-annual basis.
Based on the prospective longitudinal DPV database, this study undertook to compare with the data available for the general population the age at onset of puberty and pubertal development in a population-based cohort of German children and adolescents with type 1 diabetes, and to provide a cross-sectional analysis of the potential effects of glycemic control, body mass index (BMI), relative diabetes duration, insulin dose, and insulin therapy intensity on pubertal onset and development, including age at menarche.
| Research design and methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Anonymous longitudinal data for a cohort of 24 385 pediatric type 1 diabetic patients (12 756 boys and 11 629 girls) aged 7.0 to <17.0 years (mean 13.9 years) with documented age of diabetes onset were selected for cross-sectional statistical analysis based on the following main inclusion criteria: a) age <20 years at last visit prior to January 1, 2006 and b) ethnicity (both parents born in Germany). Stages of pubertal development and sexual maturity were defined as Tanner stages of puberty (10, 11). Sexual maturity was defined as the attainment of Tanner stage 5 of genital (boys), breast (girls), and pubic hair (both sexes) development. Data on Tanner stages were available for a total of 13 627 children and adolescents (6853 (50.3%) boys and 6774 (49.7%) girls). Data on Tanner stage 2 as a marker of pubertal onset were available for 5045 patients (2409 (47.7%) boys and 2636 (52.3%) girls). Datasets for both Tanner stage 2 and at least one independent variable were available for 4987 patients (2409 (48.3%) boys and 2578 (51.7%) girls). Menarche and diabetes onset data were available for 643 out of 11 413 girls, of whom 579 had complete datasets for multivariate analysis. The patients selected for analysis of Tanner stage 2 and menarche were in the age ranges 7.0 to <17.0 and 8.0 to <18.0 years respectively. Patients with celiac disease were excluded.
Data collection
Data were obtained as of December 31, 2005, from the database of the DPV, the German diabetes documentation, and quality management system (9), to which 202 participating diabetes care centers (hospitals, clinics, and diabetes specialists in private practice) contributed data twice yearly. The data were verified, corrected at the original center if necessary, and entered into the database using the Visual FoxPro 9.0 (Microsoft, Redmond, WA, USA) derived DPV software for standardized prospective longitudinal documentation of diabetes in children, adolescents, and adults (12). Each center complied with local ethical and data management guidelines as reported previously (13). All data were collected during routine care. The responsible ethics committee was informed of the study and had no concerns.
Dependent variables
Age at onset of puberty The age for each Tanner stage of pubertal development was calculated as the examination date at which it was first observed minus the date of birth. Age of pubertal onset was defined as the attainment of Tanner stage 2 of genital (scrotal) development (boys), breast development (girls), or pubic hair growth (boys and girls), whichever occurred first.
Age at menarche This was calculated as the date of first menses reported at the first subsequent examination minus the date of birth.
For the purposes of the present analysis, all age data were rounded to the first decimal place.
Overall mean ages at Tanner stages 2–5 and mean age at menarche in the general population of eastern Germany served as reference data in the absence of standard values for Germany as a whole. The reference data were based on longitudinal multicenter data from a cohort initiated in the former German Democratic Republic in the mid-1980s as by Greil & Kahl in 2005 (14).
Independent variables
HbA1c The quality of glycemic control was assessed by HbA1c. HbA1c levels were determined using the methodology established at each individual center. To adjust for differences among participating laboratories, the HbA1c data were mathematically standardized according to the Diabetes Control and Complications Trial (DCCT) reference range of 4.05–6.05% (HbA1c-DCCT) (15).
Relative diabetes duration This was the proportion of a patient's life with type 1 diabetes, calculated as the duration of diabetes relative to chronological age at Tanner stage 2 or menarche.
BMI SDS The BMI (kg/m2) was calculated as a patient's body weight in kilograms divided by the square of his/her height in meters. To account for the non-normal distribution of the BMI in the population, BMI SD scores (BMI SDS) were calculated according to the LMS method (16) as adapted by Kromeyer-Hauschild et al. (17) for calculating standard percentile curves of BMI for children and adolescents in Germany. Normative BMI data for German children, adolescents, and adults used in the DPV software were based on Kromeyer-Hauschild et al. (17) and Hebebrand et al. (18).
Insulin dose This was analyzed as daily units of insulin per kilogram body weight.
Intensity of insulin therapy This was represented by the mean number of daily insulin injection time points, with regimens ranging from one to seven daily injections.
Statistical analyses
All statistical analyses were carried out using SAS software (SAS Version 9.1, SAS Institute, Cary, NC, USA) and the Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS Base 13; SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA). Values of P<0.05 were considered to indicate statistical significance in all analyses. Using the mixed SAS procedure, stepwise multivariate linear regression analyses were performed for patients whose datasets were complete in respect of the independent variables of interest in order to identify variables influencing age at onset of puberty (Tanner stage 2) and age at menarche. Mean values were tested for significant difference using the t-test for unpaired samples. Differences between variances were tested using the F-test.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
As shown in Table 2, analysis of the data for our study cohort revealed highly significant delay in the onset of puberty as defined by Tanner stage 2 of genital (scrotal) development (G2) or pubic hair growth (PH2) in diabetic boys and breast development (B2) or pubic hair growth (PH2) in diabetic girls. Significant delay was also observed for the subsequent stages of pubertal development up to G4 and PH4 in boys and B3 and PH4 in girls. Sexual maturity as evidenced by Tanner stages G5 and PH5 in diabetic boys and B5 and PH5 in diabetic girls, however, occurred at statistically non-significantly earlier ages than in the reference population, while the B4 ages for diabetic and healthy girls were virtually identical. Comparisons of mean ages for Tanner stages were based on reference data for the general population of eastern Germany derived from a multicenter study of a cohort initiated in the mid-1980s (14).
|
4 weeks, Fig. 1). Also, girls who at the time of menarche had had type 1 diabetes for half their lives (relative diabetes duration 0.5) experienced their first menses at an average of 0.47 years later than those whose diabetes onset coincided with first menses (relative diabetes duration 0.0), again according to the linear regression estimate based on the raw data for 615 girls (Fig. 2).
|
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
As a chronic disease also occurring in childhood, type 1 diabetes is a factor potentially affecting the onset of male and female puberty and pubertal development, including age at menarche. Our analysis of current DPV data showed type 1 diabetes to be associated with significant mean delays in pubertal onset by 0.88 and 0.39 years for the male G2 and PH2 Tanner stages and by 0.51 and 0.08 years for the female B2 and PH2 Tanner stages respectively, compared with healthy boys and girls in the German general population. Our analysis further indicated that the differences between the study cohort and the general population decreased for Tanner stages 3–5. This suggests that diabetic children catch up to healthy children as pubertal development progresses and ultimately reach sexual maturity at a normal age, as evidenced by – statistically non-significantly – earlier attainment of Tanner stage 5 of genital (boys), breast (girls), and pubic hair (both sexes) development.
Interestingly, however, menarche, a mid-pubertal event, was found to occur with a 0.52-year delay at a mean age of 13.22 years in type 1 diabetic girls, although pubertal development at that age had already reached the normal female Tanner stages B3–B4 and PH3–PH4. Possible causes of the observed delay in menarcheal age in type 1 diabetic girls may lie at the hypothalamic–pituitary level. Clinically, female patients with type 1 diabetes may show oligomenorrhea and amenorrhea (2, 8, 23). There have also been reports of decreased luteinizing hormone (LH) levels, suggesting impairment of the hypothalamic–pituitary axis (24). Furthermore, since delayed menarche is a potential risk factor for irregular menstrual cycles and decreased bone mineral density possibly leading to later subfertility and osteoporosis (3), evidence confirming menarcheal delay may have clinical implications for improving the treatment of diabetes to help prevent such subsequent complications.
HbA1c was found in our study cohort to correlate significantly with the age of pubertal onset in boys and girls together, as well as in boys alone and girls alone, and with age at menarche, the latter confirming previous findings of a study from the United States (3). One possible explanation for this correlation is that type 1 diabetes is associated with markedly increased serum levels of glycosylated products (25), indicating that such advanced glycation end products, e.g., various proteins, may act to suppress activation of the LH-releasing hormone (LHRH) pulse generator during puberty, resulting in pubertal delay in general and delayed menarche in particular. Another explanation might be that elevated serum HbA1c levels indicate an overall chronic lack of insulin. It is well known that insulin not only signals satiety in the hypothalamus but is also involved in the regulation of reproductive function as demonstrated in vitro and in vivo (26–28). Knockout mice lacking the neuronal insulin receptor experience central hypogonadism, reduced spermatogenesis, and impaired maturation of ovarian follicles (26). Furthermore, intact mice respond to artificially increased serum insulin levels with increases in LH levels due to a hypothalamic insulin effect (27). There is evidence that insulin might regulate LHRH neuronal function directly via insulin receptors expressed on LHRH neurons (28). Disruption of normal LHRH neuronal function due to lack of insulin might be present in type 1 diabetic children, resulting in delayed onset of puberty.
Another notable finding in our present study was that age of pubertal onset was significantly associated with BMI SDS in boys and girls together, boys alone, and girls alone. Menarche was significantly inversely associated with BMI SDS and tended to occur earlier in type 1 diabetic girls with a high BMI SDS than in those with a low BMI SDS. This is in agreement with the established fact that nutritional status plays an important role in the onset and progression of female puberty. While premature puberty can be triggered by an increased BMI (22, 29), malnutrition leads to a delay in the onset of puberty and menarche (21). Moreover, delayed puberty, and menarche in particular, has been reported in girls who participate in competitive sports (19).
Age at menarche was also found to be significantly associated with relative type 1 diabetes duration in our study. The longer the premenarcheal period with type 1 diabetes, the greater was the delay in the onset of first menses. This observation lends support to the hypothesis that, in the presence of diabetes mellitus, antibodies to ovarian cells impair ovarian function (30). Thus, the earlier the onset of type 1 diabetes occurs during the prepubertal period, the greater is the likelihood that such antibodies could have already formed and resulted in ovarian functional impairment. However, the present study did not experimentally investigate this hypothesis.
A delay in menarche and/or irregularity of the menstrual cycle could also be indicative of ovarian dysregulation. As ovarian insulin receptors play an important role in ovarian function, increased HbA1c levels due to the lack of tightly regulated insulin levels may affect ovarian maturation and function, and hence pubertal development in type 1 diabetes (31). Based on this explanation, insulin dose would be expected to have a normalizing effect on age of pubertal onset and age at menarche. Our study confirmed this effect for age at menarche but not for pubertal onset. Girls treated with a higher insulin dose in our study cohort experienced their first menses earlier, whereas those on a lower dose had their first menses later. However, this finding was also not unexpected since insulin dosage depends on body weight, among other factors.
To summarize, analysis of the DPV data for our study cohort revealed significant delay in pubertal onset and age at menarche, though ultimately sexual maturity, i.e., Tanner stage 5, was attained at a normal age. We conclude that type 1 diabetes can cause delay in the onset of male and female puberty and menarche, which increases with glycohemoglobin levels or, conversely, decreases with improved glycemic control. Inversely, decreases in BMI SDS are associated with delayed pubertal onset and menarche. Regarding menarche, we additionally conclude that the longer the prepubertal duration of type 1 diabetes, i.e., the earlier diabetes onset occurs, the more likely menarche is to be delayed. In addition, menarcheal age is associated with insulin dose but not with the number of daily injections. In conclusion, it is of great clinical importance to improve glycemic control, as the most readily modifiable factor, to reduce delay in male and female pubertal onset and menarche in type 1 diabetic children.
| Acknowledgements |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |